Short answer: open the business page, scroll below the recommended reviews and click “reviews that are not currently recommended”. If the review is listed there, it was never deleted. If it is not, it was either removed for breaking Yelp’s rules or never fully posted. Each of those has a different answer, and one of them has no fix at all.
Start with where the review went, not whether it is gone
“Not showing” covers four separate situations on Yelp:
- The review is in the not-recommended section.
- Yelp removed it.
- It was never published, for example because it is still a draft.
- The page is not showing reviews the way you expect.
Check them in that order. The first is the one Yelp’s own help pages spend most time on, and it is the easiest to confirm.
What Yelp says its recommendation software does
Yelp runs every review through automated software that decides which ones appear in the main list. Its help page says that “the software looks at hundreds of factors, including various measurements of quality, reliability, and user activity of reviewers on Yelp.” It then filters out “potentially unreliable reviews, like those that may be solicited, come from an unfairly biased source (like a business owner or employee) or are written by users we just don’t know enough about.”
That last group matters most to an owner looking at a missing five-star review from a regular. Yelp says plainly that “many are real reviews from real customers who we just don’t know much about and therefore can’t recommend.” A review being left out of the main list is no accusation against you or your customer. Very often it reflects how little Yelp knows about the person who wrote it.
Yelp also says the software “runs on a daily basis, so the results can change day-to-day”. A reviewer who becomes more active may see their review move into the main list later. The reverse can happen too: Yelp notes “the information we have about a reviewer can grow stale.”
Yelp does not publish the individual factors beyond that, so treat any confident list of “signals” you find online as guesswork.
How to find not-recommended reviews on your own page
Yelp says these reviews “don’t disappear; they can still be viewed by clicking “reviews that are not currently recommended” below the recommended reviews on business pages.” They also stay visible on the reviewer’s own profile page.
Two consequences follow. First, Yelp says not-recommended reviews “don’t factor into a business’s overall star rating or review count”. If a customer tells you they left a review and your count has not moved, this is the likely reason. Second, the reviewer can usually still see their review, which is why a customer may insist it is “up” when you cannot find it on the page. Yelp’s own test for reviewers is simple: “If you see your review on your profile but don’t see it on the business page, it is not currently being recommended.”
The Google version of this mismatch, where the writer can see a review and nobody else can, works differently. If that is what you are dealing with, see my review isn’t showing for other people.
When a review was removed rather than not recommended
A removed review is gone from the business page, the not-recommended section and the reviewer’s profile. Yelp says “reviews are only removed if they are found to be in violation of our Content Guidelines or Terms of Service, or if your account has been closed all together”, and that “in most cases, if Yelp removes your review, you will be notified via email by our Support team.” So a reviewer whose review has vanished everywhere should check their email first.
Yelp’s reporting article gives four main reasons it removes a review: the reviewer has an apparent conflict of interest, the review does not focus on the reviewer’s own consumer experience, it includes inappropriate material, or it contains false information that is “materially and demonstrably false (not opinion)”.
If you believe a review on your page breaks those rules, report it from your Yelp for Business account: find the review in the Reviews section, click the More Options button (the three dots) and choose Report Review. Yelp says you may need to claim your business page before you can report from a business account. Moderators check the review against the Content Guidelines, which “may take several days”, and Yelp is clear that “reporting it doesn’t guarantee it will be removed”. For conflict-of-interest reports, it adds that “it usually isn’t enough to say that you’re suspicious of a bias”, so give specific evidence.
The Google process has its own rules and its own appeal route, covered in why a Google review was removed.
When a review was never published
Sometimes the review never went live. Yelp’s “Where is my review?” article lists two reasons that have nothing to do with the software: the review “may still be saved as a draft”, or the reviewer “may still need to confirm your email address”. Only the reviewer can fix either one, from their own account. If a customer says they reviewed you and it appears nowhere, including the not-recommended section, these are worth mentioning to them.
On timing, Yelp’s help pages give no figure for how long a new review takes to appear, so we will not invent one.
What a business can and cannot do about it
There is no lever to pull here, and Yelp says so in several places.
- Nobody at Yelp can move a review for you. “No employee at Yelp has the ability to recommend or not recommend a business’s reviews.”
- Advertising does not change it. Yelp says “other than giving advertisers ads, advertisers don’t get any preferential treatment”, and that the software “treats reviews of advertisers and non-advertisers exactly the same.”
- Asking for reviews works against you on Yelp. Its “Don’t Ask for Reviews” article says the software “actively tries to identify and not recommend reviews prompted or encouraged by the business”, and that its Business Owner Guidelines “make clear that businesses should not ask for Yelp reviews.” It tells owners not to ask customers, mailing list subscribers, friends or family, not to have staff compete to collect reviews, not to run surveys that ask happy customers for reviews, and never to offer “freebies, discounts, or payment in exchange for reviews”.
This is stricter than Google, which does allow businesses to ask for reviews. On Yelp, follow Yelp’s rule.
UK law applies on top of any platform’s rules. The Competition and Markets Authority’s fake reviews guidance, made under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, treats fake reviews and “concealed incentivised reviews” as banned content. Do not buy, gate or incentivise reviews on any platform.
If a genuine review stays in the not-recommended section, there is nothing you can do to move it. That is frustrating, but it also means competitors cannot pay to get your good reviews hidden.
If the page itself shows no reviews at all
If your page shows no reviews in the main list, check the “not currently recommended” link before anything else, because a page can have every review sitting there. Yelp’s help pages that we read do not cover a business page failing to load reviews at all, so we cannot give you a Yelp-sourced cause for that. If reviews you know are recommended do not appear, use the contact options in Yelp’s Support Center.
When it was a Google review you meant
Plenty of people searching “reviews not showing up” mean Google. reviewsnot.com is not affiliated with Yelp or any review platform, and all of our problem pages cover Google so far. Start with the showing up and showing families, or go straight to reviews not showing on Google Maps. The full list is on the problems page.